Luke 2:18
And all who heard it were amazed at what the shepherds said to them — the universal amazement (ethaumasan pantes) at the shepherds' report communicates the appropriate response to the good news. The amazement does not yet involve understanding or commitment — it is the first shock of encountering the genuinely extraordinary. The amazement at the shepherds' story is Luke's note that the nativity announcement made an immediate impact on those who heard it.