I've taught this story to middle schoolers a hundred times, and the question I always ask is: did the spies see the same land? Of course they did. But ten of them saw obstacles. Two of them saw promises. Same evidence. Opposite interpretations.
The land really was inhabited by giants. The walls really were impressive. Caleb and Joshua aren't denying reality. They're saying: God promised it to us. We are capable. This is possible. The ten are saying: we can't do it. It's impossible.
What changed my teaching was realizing this isn't actually about optimism versus pessimism. It's about faith. Caleb's faith in God's character and power allows him to see the same threats and say nonetheless. The faithless see the same threats and let those be the final word.
I think about the kids in my class who are struggling academically or socially, and I see them starting to interpret their challenges the way the ten spies did - as evidence of impossibility. How do I help them develop Caleb's eyes? How do I help them see their land as promised, even when the obstacles are real?
No comments yet. Be the first.